Hegemonic or Marginal Perspective!? The Many Shades of Nostalgia in Post-communist Romania
Ключови думи :
Anticommunism; Dominant Narratives; Intergenerational Memory; Pink NostalgiaАбстракт
In Romania, communism was declared, on December 18, 2006, an ‘illegitimate and criminal regime’. From this moment on, the main paradigm of remembering communism in the public space was anticommunism. However, ordinary people seem to remember communism in a more positive tune as shown by the various polls which measure a constantly increasing appreciation for the fallen regime. The explanations for this nostalgia are various: from ‘longing for a lost past’ to a form of counter-memory, as a critique of the present, and a fear for the future. Another explana-tion is the commodification of communism which became another marchandise to be consummed. A more subtle form of nostalgia was fuelled by the Romanian intelligentia in the 2000s, which can be explained by a change of generation, which did not feel represented either by the anticommunist discourse or the regret for a fallen regime measured by the polls. My article deals with the various forms of nostalgia recorded in Romania in the last 36 years since the fall of communism aiming at describing them, offering some explanations while trying to understand the trends and mechanisms of both ‘reflective’ and ‘restorative’ forms of nostalgia.
Литература (библиография)
Agamben, G. (1989). Enfance et histoire. Dépérissement de l’expérience et origine de l’histoire. Payot.
Anton, M. (2020). Comunismul în post-comunism. Nostalgii și nostalgici. Po-lis, VIII, 3 (29), 5-33.
Appadurai, A. (1996). Modernity at large. Cultural Dimensions of Globali-zation. University of Minnesota Press.
Arnold-Forster, A. (2025). Nostalgia. Povestea unei emoții periculoase. Humanitas.
Asavei, M.-A. (2016). Nicolae Ceauşescu: between Vernacular Memory and Nostalgia. Twenty Century Communism, 11, 27-42.
Bardan, Al. (2018). Marketing Post-communist Nostalgia in Romania. A Case Study on Contemporary Anniversary Events. Style of Communication, 10 (1), 50-73.
Bardan, Al. (2020). Nostalgia Waves: A Media Framing of Post-communist Nostalgia in Romania. Polis, VIII, 3 (29), 35-50.
Barney, T. (2009). When we was red: Good Bye Lenin! and nostalgia for the everyday GDR. Communication and Critical/Cultural Studies, 6 (2), 132-151.
Berliner, D. (2020). Losing Culture. Nostalgia, Heritage, and Our Acceler-ated Times. Rutgers University Press.
Boghiceanu, A. (2017). Infografie sondaj: Peste jumătate dintre români încă mai suspină după communism. Adevărul, 18 September 2017. http://adevarul.ro/news/politica/sondaj-jumatate-romani-inca-mai-suspina-comunism-1_5419ba120d133766a835cd90/index.html (Retrieved 4 June 2017).
Bonnard, P., Jouhanneau, C. (2017). Governing the Memories of Com-munism in Central and Eastern Europe: Policy Instruments and Social Practices. European Politics and Society, 18 (1), 1-9.
Boym, S. (2001). The Future of Nostalgia. Basic Books.
Cârneci. M. (2014). Ciocan vs. Ulyanov, Proiect 1: 26/01/2010-27/01/2010. In Ciocan I. (ed.). Proiect1990, Program de artă în spațiul public 2010-2014/Art in Public Spaces Program 2010-2014.Vellant.
Centrul Național al Cinematografiei, Total spectatori la filmul românesc, 2019,https://cnc.gov.ro/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/TOTAL-SPECTATORI-FILM-ROMANESC-LA-31.12.2019.pdf (Retrieved 24 July 2025).
Cernat, P. (2004). Texte “reconstitutive” și zone de profunzime. Observator Cultural, 234.
Cernat, P., Manolescu, I., Mitchievici, A., Stanomir, I. (2001). În căutarea comunismului pierdut. Editura Paralela 45.
Cioflâncă, A. (2010). Nostalgia pentru communism. Revista 22, 28 Septem-ber 2010. https://revista22.ro/vis-a-vis/adrian-cioflanca/nostalgia-pentru-comunism (Retrieved 27 July 2025).
Cohen, N. (2021). Our politics of nostalgia is a sure sign of present-day de-cay. The Guardian, 26 June 2021. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/jun/26/our-politics-of-nostalgia-is-a-sure-sign-of-present-day-decay (Retrieved 20 July 2025).
Creed, G. W. (2010). Strange Bedfellows: Socialist Nostalgia and Neoliberal-ism in Bulgaria. In Todorova, M., Gille, Z. (eds.) (2010). Post-communist nostalgia. Berghahn Books, 29-45
Davis, F. (1979). Yearning for Yesterday: A Sociology of Nostalgia. Collier Macmillan Publishers, The Free Press.
De Certeau, M. (1984). The practices of everyday life. University of Califor-nia Press.
Decuble, G. H. (ed.) (2004). Cartea roz a comunismului. vol. 1. Versus.
Despa, O. (2022). Istoric: Georgescu este precar din punct de vedere intelec-tual și cultural, promotor al ideilor legionare. Europa Liberă România. 1 February 2022.https://romania.europalibera.org/a/dorin-dobrincu-despre-legionarism-aur/31681618.html (Retrieved 25 July 2025).
Dobre, C.-F. (2023). Between Deprivation and Privilege: (Former) „Enemies of the People” in Communist and Postcommunist Romania. Balkanistic Forum, XXXII (2), 32-49.
Dobre, C.-F. (ed.) (2020). Eroine neștiute. Viața cotidiană a femeilor în per-ioada comunistă în Polonia, România și RDG. Studii de caz. Cetatea de Scaun.
Dobre, C.-F. (2023). Fostele deținute politic și Securitatea. Studiu de caz. Cetatea de Scaun.
Dobre, C.-F. (2024). Historia y Memoria en Rumania Postcomunista. Edito-rial Aula de Humanidades.
Dobre, C.-F. (2011). Les vingt ans du postcommunisme roumain: L’espace public et les mémoires du communisme. Sensus Historiae, 5 (4), 25-45.
Dobre, C.-F. (2021). Martore fără voie. Fostele deținute politic și memoria comunismului în România. Cetatea de Scaun.
Dobre, C.-F. (2024). Mediating the Recent Past: Museums and Memorials dealing with the Communist Past. MediCult, Revista de Mediere Culturală, 3, 5-25.
Dobre, C.-F. (2017). Memorial Regimes and Memory Updates in Post-communist Romania. Sensus Historiae, 2 (27), 23-43.
Dobre, C.-F. (2025). Memoriile comunismului în România: reprezentări pub-lice și individuale. Revista Istorica, 1-2, (forthcoming).
Dobre, C.-F. (2019). Ni victime, ni héroïne: les anciennes détenues poli-tiques et les mémoires du communisme en Roumanie. Electra.
Dobre, C.-F. (2018). Remembering Communism in Post-Communist Roma-nia: Memorial Regimes and Individual Recollections. Studii și Materiale de Istorie Contemporană, 17, 155-173.
Dobre, C.-F. (2021). The Patrimonialization of the Communist Past in Ro-mania: Laws, Memorials, and Monuments. Balkanistic Forum, 1, 179-195.
Dobre, C.-F., Jonda, B., Skorzynska, I., Wachowiak, A. (2019). (Re)gaining the Future by (Re)building the Past. Women`s Narratives of Life under Communism in Poland, Romania and the Former East Germany. Poznan University Press.
Ecourile lui 26 ianuarie peste timp. Ediţie specială „Dosar România”, la TVR 1. (2023). 25 January 2023. https://www.tvr.ro/ecourile-lui-26-ianuarie-peste-timp-editie-speciala-dosar-romania-la-tvr-1_39322.html (Retrieved 24 July 2025).
Fundația pentru o Societate Deschisă. Actuala percepție despre comunism (2006). www.osf.ro (Retrieved 7 February 2007).
Gabriel, Y. (1993). Organisational Nostalgia: Reflections on the Golden Age. In Fineman, S. (ed.) (1993). Emotions in Organisations. Sage Publications, 118-141.
Gaston, S., Hilhorst, S. (2018). Nostalgia as a Cultural and Political Force in Britain, France and Germany. Demos.
Georgescu, D. (2010). “Ceaușescu Hasn’t died”: Irony as CounterMemory in Post-Socialist Romania. In Todorova, M., Gille, Z. (eds.) (2010). Post-communist nostalgia. Berghahn Books, 155-176.
Goulding, C. (2001). Romancing the past: Heritage visiting and the nostalgic consumer. Psychology and Marketing, 18 (6), 565-592.
Hartog, Fr. (2003). Régimes d'historicité: présentisme et expériences du temps. Seuil.
Hurezean, R. (2025). Românii și nostalgia comunismului. De ce îl consideră un trecut „mai sigur și mai bun”. PRESShub, 18 January 2025. https://www.presshub.ro/romanii-si-nostalgia-comunismului-de-ce-il-considera-un-trecut-mai-sigur-si-mai-bun-359584/ (Retrieved 20 July 2025).
IULIE 2025: Sondaj de opinie INSCOP Research: Percepția populației cu privire la regimul comunist. Reperele nostalgiei. (2025) https://www.inscop.ro/iulie-2025-sondaj-de-opinie-inscop-research-perceptia-populatiei-cu-privire-la-regimul-comunist-reperele-nostalgiei/ (Retrieved 24 July 2025).
Jameson, F. (1989). Nostalgia for the Present. South Atlantic Quarterly, 88 (2), 517-537.
Kenny, M. (2017). Back to the populist future?: Understanding nostalgia in contemporary ideological discourse. Journal of Political Ideologies, 22 (3), 1-18.
Kideckel, D. (2004). The Undead: Nicolae Ceaușescu and Paternalistic Poli-tics in Romanian Society and Culture. In Borneman J. (ed.) (2004). Death of the Father. An Anthropology of the End in Political Authority. Berghahn Books, 123-147.
Koleva, D. (2011). Hope for the Past? Postsocialist Nostalgia 20 Years Later. In Hayoz, N., Jesien, L., Koleva, D. (eds.) (2011). 20 Years after the Collapse of Communism. Expectations, achievements, and disillusions of 1989. Peter Lang.
Legg, St. (2007). Reviewing Geographies of Memory/Forgetting. Envi-ronement and Planning A, 39 (2), 456-466.
Light, D., Young, C. (2015). Local and counter-memories of socialism in post-socialist Romania. In Beyen, M., Deseure, B. (eds.) (2015). Local Memories in a Nationalizing and Globalizing World. Palgrave, 221-243.
Lowenthal, D. (2015). The Past is a Foreign Country. Revisted. Cambridge University Press.
Manolache, E. (2011). Sondaj CSOP-IICCMER: Peste 60% dintre români percep comunismul drept o idee bună. Agerpres, 27 May 2011. https://www.agerpres.ro/social/2011/05/27/sondaj-csop-iiccmer-peste-60-dintre-romani-percep-comunismul-drept-o-idee-buna-17-41-56 (Retrieved 16 December 2023).
Manolescu, I., Cernat, P. Mitchievici, A., Stanomir, I. (2004). O lume dispărută. Patru istorii personale urmate de un dialog cu Horia Roman Patapievici. Polirom.
Marković, P. J. (2007). Der Sozialismus und seine seieben ‘S’-Werte der Nos-talgie. In Troebst, St., Brunnbauer, U. (eds.) (2007). Zwischen Amnesie und Nostal-gie: die Erinnerung an den Kommunismus in Südosteuropa. Böhlau, 153-164.
Mari Români (2006). Wikipedia. https://ro.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mari_români (Retrieved 24 July 2025).
Marin, L. (2019). How to think critically about the Common Past? On the feeling of Post-communist Nostalgia in Post-Revolutionary Romania. Analele Uni-versității din București. Philosophy Series, LXVIII (2), 57-71.
Marin, M. (2013). Between Memory and Nostalgia: The image of Com-munism in Romanian Popular Culture. A Case Study of Libertatea Newspaper. Palimpsest, 5, 4-16.
Marin, M. (2016). Re-Assesing post-communist nostalgia in Romania: chronological framework and opinion polls. Twentieth Century Communism, 11, 10-26.
Mihăilescu, C.-A. (2006). Cum era? Cam așa... Amintiri din anii co-munismului românesc. Curtea Veche.
Milea, A. (2003). Ceaușescu n-a murit. CD. Absurdistan.
Morariu, M. (2012). From condemnation to melancholy: alternative mean-ings of post-communist nostalgia in Romania. Studia Politica: Romanian Political Science Review, 12(2), 289-308.
Murgescu, B. (2010). România și Europa. Acumularea decalajelor econom-ice (1500-2010). Polirom.
Petre, Z. (2005). Commentary on François Hartog’s conference, “Temps du monde, histoire, régimes d'historicité”, within the international conference, “Travail de mémoire et d'oubli dans les sociétés postcommunistes”. Bucharest 13-14 May 2005, minutes 2-3 and 10-11.
Petrescu, C. (2017). Nostalgia, identity and Self-Irony in Remembering Communism. In Stan, L., Turcescu, L. (eds) (2017). Justice, Memory and Redress in Romania: New Insights. Cambridge Scholars Publishing,192-213.
Popa, C. (2024). Reformele anului 1967 sau de ce „liberalismul” lui Ceaușescu a fost doar o ortodoxie bine mascată. Studii și Materiale de Istorie Con-temporană, 23, 103-119.
Popescu-Sandu, O. (2010). “Let’s all freeze up until 2100 or so”: Nostalgic Directions in Post-Communist Romania. In Todorova, M., Gille, Z. (eds.) (2010). Post-communist nostalgia. Berghahn Books, 113-127.
Preda, C. (2015). Le rôle de la nostalgie dans la mémoire artistique du pas-sé communiste dans la Roumanie contemporaine. Canadian Slavonic Pa-pers/Revue Canadienne des Slavistes, 57 (3-4), 268-283.
Preda, C. (2025). Nostalgic Reconstructions of the Communist Past: The Private Museums of Daily Life During Communism in Romania. In Ciobanu, M., Șerban, M. (eds.) (2025). Between the Memory and Post-Memory of Communism in Romania. Fluid Memories. Routledge, 186-205.
Preda, C. (2014). Melting, Judith Balko, Proiect 11: 24/05/2012-01/07/2012. In Ciocan I. (ed.) (2014). Proiect1990, Program de artă în spațiul public 2010-2014/Art in Public Spaces Program 2010-2014.Vellant.
Preda Sânc, M. (2014). Preamble. In Ciocan, I. (ed.) (2014). Proiect1990, Program de artă în spațiul public 2010-2014/Art in Public Spaces Program 2010-2014. Vellant.
Puhl, J., Kraske, M. (2005). Products create market for communist nostalgia in Eastern Europe. Spiegel International, 28 February 2005. https://www.spiegel.de/international/living-legends-products-create-market-for-communist-nostalgia-in-eastern-europe-a-344052.html (Retrieved 20 July 2025).
Radio Free Europe. (1998). Newsline, 30 November 1998.
https://www.rferl.org/a/1141792.html (Retrieved 12 January 2024).
Radio Free Europe. (2003). Newsline, 20 October 2003.
https://www.rferl.org/a/1143025.html (Retrieved 12 January 2024).
Raportul final al comisiei prezidențiale pentru analiza dictaturii comuniste din România. (2006). https://www.wilsoncenter.org/sites/default/files/media/documents/article/RAPORT%20FINAL_%20CADCR.pdf (Retrieved 10 August 2024).
Rusu, M. S., Croitoru, A. (2022). Ambivalențe memoriale în România postsocialistă: atitudini generaționale față de moștenirea simbolică a socialismului. In Petrescu, C., Petrescu, D. (eds.) (2022). Comunismul în România. O sută de ani de controverse. Pro Universitaria.
Rusu, M. S. (2015). Battling over Romanian red past. The memory of Com-munism between elitist cultural trauma and popular collective nostalgia. The Roma-nian Journal of Society and Politics, 10 (1), 24-48.
Sierp, A. (2009). Nostalgia for Times Past. On the Uses and Abuses of the Ostalgie Phenomenon in Eastern Germany. Contemporary European Studies 4(2), 47-60.
Sondaj: 41% dintre romani spun că l-ar vota pe Nicolae Ceaușescu în funcția de președinte al României. (2010). HotNews.ro, 26 July 2010. https://hotnews.ro/sondaj-41-dintre-romani-spun-ca-l-ar-vota-pe-nicolae-ceausescu-in-functia-de-presedinte-al-romaniei-717850 (Retrieved 20 July 2025).
Sondaj INSCOP: A crescut numărul românilor care cred că regimul co-munist a însemnat un lucru bun. (2023). Euractiv.ro, 13 December 2023. https://www.euractiv.ro/social/sondaj-inscop-a-crescut-numarul-romanilor-care-cred-ca-regimul-comunist-a-insemnat-un-lucru-bun-64854 (Retrieved 16 December 2023).
Sondaj IRES (2014). Ceauşescu ar câştiga detaşat dacă ar candida anul acesta la prezidenţiale (SONDAJ IRES). jurnalul.ro, 10 April 2014.
https:///jurnalul.ro/stiri/politica/sondaj-ires-ceausescu-665661.html (Retrieved 25 July 2025).
Sondaj (2018). Radu Eremia. Topul preşedinţilor României, după simpatia populară. Ce părere au românii despre foştii şefi de stat. Adevărul.ro, 26 December 2018.https://adevarul.ro/politica/sondaj-topul-presedintilor-romaniei-dupa-1913795.html (Retrieved 25 July 2025).
Spaskovska, L. (2008). Recommunaissance: On the phenomenon of com-munist nostalgia in Slovenia and Poland. Anthropological Journal of European Cultures, 17 (1), 136-150.
The Pew (2009). Two Decades after the Wall’s Fall. End of Communism Cheered but now with more Reservations. The Pew Global Project Attitudes. 2 No-vember 2009.
Todorova, M. (2010). Introduction. From Utopia to Propaganda and Back. In Todorova, M., Gille, Z. (eds.) (2010). Post-communist nostalgia. Berghahn Books, 1-16.
Todorova, M., Gille, Z. (eds.) (2010). Post-communist nostalgia. Berghahn Books.
Toșa, D. (2025). Călin Georgescu: Condamnarea comunismului în România: O RUȘINE! Revoluția: O lovitură de Stat!. Newsweek. Romania. 27 Jan-uary 2025. https://newsweek.ro/politica/calin-georgescu-condamnarea-comunismului-in-parlament-o-rusine-revolutia-o-lovitura-de-stat (Retrieved 25 July 2025).
Troebst, St., Brunnbauer, U. (eds.) (2006). Zwischen Nostalgie, Amnesie und Allergie: Erinnerung an den Kommunismus in Südosteuropa. Böhlau Verlag.
Tanner, Gr. (2021). The Hours Have Lost Their Clock: The Politics of Nos-talgia. Watkins Media Limited.
van der Velden, M., López Ortega, A., Roth, D. J., Guldemond, P. (2023). Do We All Long for the Past? Investigating Nostalgia as a Persuasive Political Rhe-torical Strategy. OSF, preprint from 27 October 2023. https://osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/3ka95_v1 (Retrieved 20 July 2025) DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31235/osf.io/3ka95.
Volčič, Z. (2007). Yugo-Nostalgia: Cultural Memory and Media in the For-mer Yugoslavia. Critical Studies in Media Communication, 24 (1), 21-38.
Файлове за сваляне
Публикуван
Брой
Раздел (Секция)
Лиценз
Авторски права (c) 2026 BALKANISTIC WORLDS
Публикация с Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
